Iceplant is a perennial with thick leaves and upright stems, widely grown in U.S. gardens. Its flat-topped clusters of small pink flowers open from late summer into fall and attract butterflies. It is also widely called showy stonecrop.
Orpine usually has yellow and a more rounded flower head; iceplant has purple anthers and a flatter head. Leaf positions overlap, so check open flowers rather than relying on leaves alone.
Why they get mixed upBoth are tall garden stonecrops with fleshy leaves and dense late-season flower heads.