Welted thistle, also called curly plumeless thistle, is a spiny Eurasian thistle whose stems carry prickly, ribbon-like wings. In the United States it's an introduced weed of pastures and roadsides, and several states regulate it.

Appearance

Appearance
A branching usually 2–6 ft (0.5–1.8 m) tall, occasionally taller. Spiny wings run down the stems and up the flower stalks.
Leaves
Leaves are 4–8 in (10–20 cm) long with spiny-toothed or lobed edges. The undersides are covered in white, felt-like hair.
Flowers
Small heads about 5/8–3/4 in (15–18 mm) across, often in clusters of 2–5 at the stem tips. Usually purple or pink, sometimes white.
Fruit
Small, flattened, yellowish- to grayish-brown seeds tipped with a tuft of white hairs.

Look-alikes

plumeless thistleCarduus acanthoides

The two are hard to separate at a glance. Welted thistle's leaves are covered in white, felt-like hair underneath, while plumeless thistle's undersides are only somewhat hairy.

Why they get mixed upIt's a close relative, it's far more common in the US, and it also has spiny winged stems.

bull thistleCirsium vulgare

Bull thistle's leaves feel rough on top from tiny spines, and its flower heads are usually bigger. Its seed hairs are feathery, while welted thistle's are plain and unbranched.

Why they get mixed upBoth are weedy thistles with spiny wings on the stems.

Canada thistleCirsium arvense

Canada thistle's stems have no wings and no spines. Welted thistle's stems are winged and prickly.

Where it lives

Typical habitats
  • old fields
  • pastures
  • roadsides
  • stream banks
  • disturbed ground
Range
Native to Europe and Asia. Naturalized in scattered parts of the United States and Canada, and also in Greenland and India.
Preferred conditions
Needs full sun and moist, rich soil. It moves into disturbed places such as old fields, logging sites, rail yards, and stream banks.

Life cycle

Seed dispersal
The hairy tufts carry the seeds on the wind.

Conservation

IUCN Red List
NENot EvaluatedNot yet assessed
Status
Listed as invasive or noxious in states including California, Maryland, Oregon, Virginia, and West Virginia.

More species to explore

Record what you meet and build your own collection

Your photos are kept with their date and place, and you can fill regional albums one species at a time.

Welted Thistle (Carduus crispus) — identification, habitat & look-alikes | Moeyo